Sam and Max Episode 2: Situation: Comedy Review

Well, it seems like only weeks ago I was playing and then reviewing Sam and Max: Culture Shock, the highly anticipated point-and-click adventure game, the first in a series of episodic games from the folks at Telltale.  Wouldn’t you know it, just a few weeks after the release of Episode 1, Episode 2: Situation Comedy was released, far trumping Valve’s attempts at timely episodic content.

Now, as this game uses the same engine as Episode 1 and is very similar in terms of gameplay, graphics, and sound, this review will be as concise as possible, since I see no need to reinvent the proverbial wheel.

Having successfully thwarted the evil plans of self-help guru Brady Culture and his use of hypnotism, our heroes Sam and Max were yet again sitting around the office looking for things to shoot… err… do.  A call was all it took for our heroes to discover that famous talk show host Myra (think Oprah meets Tyra Banks) has decided to take her audience captive and continues to force them to accept her free give-aways (in this case a lifetime supply of soap, among other items).  It will be up to our steadfast heroes Sam and Max to save the day yet again.

   

As the second episode in an episodic adventure game series, Situation Comedy supplies precisely what you would expect, in that it is more of what we saw in the first game.  More humor, more dialogue choices, more driving mini-games and more hunting for items and inventory management.  However, instead of launching Episode 2 with a sequel mentality of “bigger and better than part 1,” we instead see a backslide in terms of what we receive.

Situation Comedy seems to suffer from the “more of the same” syndrome.  Namely, we get more of the same pun-filled and witty banter between Sam, Max, and the many colorful characters to whom we are introduced.  Personally, I found myself laughing significantly less in Episode 2 than I did in Episode 1, and perhaps this was due in part to the fact that it was very similar in presentation to Episode 1.  For instance, many of the descriptions of items found in the various areas, especially the office, seemed nearly identical to those used in the previous episode.

"Situation Comedy seems to suffer from the “more of the same” syndrome."

I also found the inclusion of the driving mini-game in this episode to be disappointing and completely unnecessary; it actually seemed to take away from the game for me.  I found the introduction of elements like the Skin Bodies and Bosco’s new identity were extremely humorous, but weren’t explored enough for me to truly appreciate them.

   

Following the theme of more of the same, Situation Comedy is structured very similarly to Culture Shock.  In this episode, you are again asked for a predetermined number of goals to be met prior to proceeding to the end-game sequence.  The puzzles tend to range from collecting items to trying various dialogue options until you get things right.  In terms of difficulty, I found Situation Comedy to be slightly easier than Culture Shock and, for those who didn’t read my previous review, this means Sam and Max Episode 2: Situation Comedy is very easy.

With episodic content, we are seeing that developers don’t seem to know how much game to include in each episode to keep people playing.  Some type of formula needs to exist, as I completed Situation Comedy in just over two hours, which was about an hour shorter than the previous episode.  I am not certain if this episode wasn’t long enough, or if I was just much more prepared for it playing through the previous episode, but I just did not enjoy it as much as I did Culture Shock.

"I just did not enjoy it as much as I did Culture Shock. "

Still, for a relatively inexpensive game that is bound to entertain you, however briefly, it is a fun experience.  I recommend this game for those who are fans of the Sam and Max series, but I recommend a pass to those looking for a longer gameplay experience for their money.  As such, if you are a fan of the series then consider it a 7 out of 10; otherwise, see the score below.

    

Pros

  • Entertaining new characters.  

  • The spoofing of pop culture continues to impress.

  • Solid voice acting and dialogue. 

Cons

  • This game is like taking the first game, removing an hour, and then the challenge.

  • What is offered in Episode 2 does not quite match the price point.


digg this article!
del.icio.us bookmark
TIPS N4G
StumbleIt
reddit
Share on Facebook


6.8/10
Gameplay: 6


Graphics: 8


Sound: 10


Value: 4


 


GoGamer 48hr Madness!
Sam and Max Episode 2: Situation: Comedy


Genre: Adventure
Publisher: Telltale / Gametap
Developer: Telltale Games

Release Date:
January 05, 2007

Link:
The Official Site
Recent Forum Topics
suggestion for a new weekly article
Grid Demo
2404 Contest Sponsored by GoGamer.com
GTA IV
article sugestions
Mass Effect
How Accurate are Video-Game Weapons?
Ultraviolet
Hello to everyone...
chat room
Recent Reviews
Penumbra: Black Plague Review
Penumbra: Overture Review
Halo 2 Review
Assassin's Creed: Director's Cut Edition Review
Sherlock Holmes: Nemesis Review
RedLynx Trials 2: Second Edition Review
Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare Review
BioShock Review
Bus Driver Review
Sam and Max Episode 201: Ice Station Santa Review
Recent Previews
Dracula: Origin Preview
Hard To Be A God Preview
Sins of a Solar Empire Preview
Agatha Christie: Evil Under the Sun Preview
European Street Racing Preview
PoxNora Preview
Defcon Preview
WarRock Preview
Guild Wars Factions Hands-On
Wild Earth Preview
Recent Editorials
Mod Squad: Half-Life 2 Part IV
Blizzcon 2007 Full Report
Mod Squad: Half-Life 2 Part III
E3 is Dead. Long live E3!
A Beginner's Guide to Lord of the Rings Online
2006 Wrap-Up
Mod Squad: Half-Life 2 Part II
Attack of the Clones!
Stung Again
Uwe Boll Conquers Critics
Recent Interviews
Uwe Boll Interview
Project Origin Interview
Unreal Tournament 3 Interview
Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare Interview
Guitar Hero III: Legends of Rock Interview
Guild Wars: Eye of the North Interview
Painkiller: Overdose Interview
World in Conflict Interview
F.E.A.R. Perseus Mandate Interview
Dungeon Runners Interview
Top 10 Games
Assassin's Creed: Director's Cut Edition
Call of Duty 2
Command and Conquer 3: Tiberium Wars
Day of Defeat Source
The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion
Star Wars Empire at War: Forces of Corruption
Age of Empires III
F.E.A.R.
World of Warcraft
Red Orchestra: Ostfront 41-45